Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Monday announced a dramatic overhaul of a decades-old food policy that allowed companies to incorporate new ingredients without federal oversight. The Trump administration has also submitted the government's first proposed definition of ultra-processed foods for final review, he said.
“Parents should not need a chemistry degree to understand what their kids are eating,” Kennedy said at an event in Washington, where he reiterated a favorite talking point linking the typical American diet with obesity and chronic disease.
“Nearly 60% of the American diet is made up of ultra-processed foods for our kids ... and more than 70% of American adults are obese or overweight,” he said. “We cannot spend our way out of a chronic disease epidemic while ignoring the things that are making Americans sick. Food is the most powerful weapon that we have in our arsenal.”
Kennedy said the Food and Drug Administration does not know exactly how many ingredients are in the U.S. food supply, saying it could be anywhere between 4,000 and 12,000. He cited a 1958 law passed by Congress to allow food manufacturers to use ingredients that are generally recognized as safe.
The GRAS framework, as it’s known, said companies did not need to conduct extensive studies about well-understood ingredients like salt, vinegar and flour. Over time, however, Kennedy said what was intended as a narrow exemption became a loophole for companies to make their own determinations about the safety of the substances they were using.
“Industry hijacked the loophole and drove a convoy of chemical trucks through it straight into the American food supply,” Kennedy said. “The FDA was left with a major blind spot, and administration after administration allowed that system to persist. And Congress has not fixed it either.”
The proposed rule would require mandatory notifications of GRAS substances by food manufacturers and expand the FDA's publicly available list of those notifications. For ingredients that are already on the market, the proposed rule would create a timeline for manufacturers to give the FDA information about how they are currently being used.
At Monday’s events, FDA officials and other public health advocates repeatedly mentioned the federal government’s first proposed definition of ultra-processed foods as a game changer. HHS has not yet publicly released its definition but said in a statement Monday that it incorporated feedback from thousands of stakeholders, including consumer groups, researchers and the food industry.
Ultra-processed foods have at least one ingredient that wouldn’t be found in a kitchen, like a chemical-based preservative, hydrogenated oil or artificial color, according to the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, which said the foods undergo processes "that leave the final products bearing almost no resemblance to the original ingredients."
“The agency continues to operate with a lack of comprehensive knowledge of the substances present in the food supply,” acting FDA Commissioner Kyle Diamantas said Monday.
He “strongly” encouraged public comment from “all stakeholders” on the rule that was made available Monday morning. The FDA will accept comments for 120 days.
The Consumer Brands Association, a U.S. trade group that represents the consumer packaged goods industry, said Monday it has serious concerns with the federal government’s efforts to define ultra-processed foods, saying it will increase consumer costs and create confusion.
“America’s packaged food supply is safe and has been a staple in American households for decades," Consumer Brands Association Executive Vice President Rhonda Bentz said in a statement. “That’s something that a guidance document crafted without credible experts cannot change. Any so-called definition that captures 80% of the nation’s food supply while picking winners and losers is fundamentally flawed, not based on sound science and politically motivated.”
Consumer Brands is a part of the coalition Americans for Ingredient Transparency — a group that is working on federal legislation that would establish national rules on ingredient safety regulations, including those that are generally recognized as safe.
During Monday’s event, Kennedy called on Congress “to give FDA the additional tools it needs to keep pace with the changing food supply” by increasing its oversight ability.
“AFIT supports meaningful, science-based modernization of the GRAS program and efforts to strengthen consumer confidence in the safety and transparency of our food supply,” AFIT senior adviser Patrice Onwuka said in a statement. “The most durable way to achieve those goals is through bipartisan Congressional action that establishes a transparent, nationally uniform framework for food ingredient oversight.”
Absent a national rule, a patchwork of states’ ingredient laws would result in a 12% increase in grocery costs, according to a recent Policy Navigation Group analysis that AFIT cited. The group also said national food transparency legislation has bipartisan support.
“In attendance today we have left-wing groups who are in bitter disagreement with us on other issues but are joining arms on these initiatives today,” HHS senior adviser Calley Means said Monday. “All of us agree there is a unique political and cultural moment where we can change the incentives of our food system and improve transparency."