School officials in Scarborough are working on an update to the district’s policy on cell phone use by students.  

The new policy may be a bit more restrictive.

“For us, we were taking a look at it in light of new material that’s been released about distraction and devices, addiction and devices, along with what are the real needs, how is it benefiting our students to have cell phones available to them in school,” said School Board Chairperson Shannon Lindstrom.

A draft of the new policy describes the devices as “including but not limited to cell phones, smartphones, tablets, smartwatches and electronic games.”

Some changes make enforcement more streamlined at all levels, but Lindstrom noted the high school has always only had a partial ban, allowing the students to use their phones outside of class. Students at the K-8 level are already expected to keep devices turned off at all times during school hours. 

The new draft, Lindstrom said, will prohibit use of cell phones at the high school during lunchtime as well, but students will still be able to use the phones during passing time between classes. She said this allows students to check in with someone outside of the school, such as a parent, if necessary.

“That’s a major change,” she said.

Lindstrom said two recent petitions – one from students and teachers, the other from parents and community members – were part of the reason the board is reconsidering the policy now.

Lindstrom added, however, that the board was already reexamining the policy, as it hadn’t been reviewed since 2017.  

“Cell phone use has dramatically changed since then,” she said. 

Other districts in Maine are also grappling with the issue of cell phone bans or restrictions. In August 2024, the Biddeford School Committee passed a similar restriction on cell phone use by students during school hours.

One of the issues that district tried to address at the time was how to allow students access to and use of phones during an emergency, such as a lockdown.

On Thursday, Lindstrom said the draft of the new policy in Scarborough does not address that issue yet, but she added that the draft is not finished. The board is aware of concerns about emergencies, she said, and is working to include language in the new policy to address those concerns. 

The board will give its second and final approval to the policy at its meeting on Feb. 27. In the meantime, Lindstrom said, the board’s policy committee will meet to iron out details such as phone access during emergencies and when the policy will take effect once approved.