Rep. Jeff Hanley wants 90% of all current and future state surplus funds returned to Maine taxpayers.

And the other 10%? It would go to the state’s rainy day fund so the state is prepared to handle economic downturns.

“The state of Maine has collected way too much money from our good taxpayers,” said Hanley, a Pittston Republican. “This tells me that our tax rates are much too high.”

During testimony to the Legislature’s Appropriations and Financial Affairs Committee on Wednesday, Hanley said Mainers are paying more for gas, oil and diesel fuel. He said although the bill as printed calls for 75% of surpluses to be sent back to taxpayers, he would like to see that increased to 90%.

The public hearing before the Legislature’s budget-writing committee comes as lawmakers await a supplemental budget proposal from Democratic Gov. Janet Mills that will outline how she would like to allocate an estimated $822 million budget surplus. She has agreed with Republicans that some of the money should be returned to taxpayers, but has been tight-lipped about how much or in what way the funds would be distributed.

Hanley’s bill seeks a longer-term solution to deal not only with the current surplus but all future surplus funds.

Hanley explained that his bill would ensure that the state meets its General Fund obligations first, then gives 90% of what’s left back to taxpayers in a “formula in proportion to taxes paid in” and the rest is allocated to the state’s rainy day fund. His bill is a concept draft, which means lawmakers on the budget panel will need to craft exact language.

Nick Murray, policy analyst for the Maine Policy Institute, said although direct checks to taxpayers are popular, it’s better to enact “direct, structural tax relief instead.”

As it is now, the state uses what’s called a cascade to distribute surplus funds. Some of the money goes to replenish accounts for loan insurance, state retiree health insurance, the rainy day fund and highways and bridges.

Opponents of Hanley’s bill – the Maine People’s Alliance and the Maine Center for Economic Policy – argued that the state has many needs that should be funded.

“Our state is in the midst of an unprecedented economic and public health crisis that has revealed how fragile and grossly underfunded our state’s social safety net is,” said Adam Zuckerman of the Maine People’s Alliance.

He said once the state has adequately funded “affordable health care, child care, housing and drug treatment,” helped service workers and addressed hunger, it would be time to consider tax breaks.

And Sarah Austin of the Maine Center for Economic Policy said the pandemic has exacerbated the divide between the wealthy and the poor.

“Getting cash to people is an important tool to help households make it through tough times, but in the climate we are in wherein many households are doing incredibly well and others are suffering greatly, it’s important for policies to be targeted so that they are able to do the most good for households that need it,” she said.

On the other side, bill co-sponsor Sen. Trey Stewart (R-Presque Isle) said since he started at the state house in 2017, the state budget has grown by more than $1 billion.

“If you ask a constituent at the grocery store whether they want that additional $1.1 billion to go to a new government program or to go back in their families’ budget to offset the increasing cost of virtually everything, my guess is they will want it back,” he said.

With Democrats in control of the House and Senate, the bill faces an uphill climb. The next step is a committee work session that will be held in the coming weeks.